Law library

Judicial reviews of decisions


Last updated: March 13, 2024

A party may seek judicial review of Tribunal decisions. See:

Tribunal decisions are listed below, if there is court decision on a judicial review application. Links to the court decisions are given, where available.

A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z

A

Complaint name and/or Tribunal decision, date and/or citationResult of judicial review, court registry information and/or decision
A v. B
2011 BCHRT 74
Petition struck – 2012 BCSC 892

Appeal dismissed – 2013 BCCA 403

Application for leave to appeal dismissed May 8, 2014 – S.C.C., File No. 35736
A v. Society and others (No. 2)
2015 BCHRT 143
2015 BCHRT 163
Petition dismissed – 2017 BCSC 1883

Appeal dismissed – 2018 BCCA 84

Application for leave to appeal dismissed February 28, 2019 – S.C.C. File No. 38383
A v. The Society,
2017 BCHRT 234
Petition allowed in part – 2019 BCSC 666
A.M. v. Her Majesty the Queen in Right of the Province of British Columbia as represented by the Ministry of Children and Family Development
2015 BCHRT 34
Petition allowed – 2017 BCSC 89
A. v. Keebler (No. 2)
2016 BCHRT 63
Petition dismissed – 2019 BCSC 1194
Abrams v. North Shore Free Press Ltd. (c.o.b. “North Shore News”)
(February 2, 1999)
Petition adjourned in part; petitioner’s constitutional challenge remitted to Tribunal – BCSC Victoria, Registry No. 99/1644

Appeal dismissed – 2001 BCCA 22

Application for leave to appeal dismissed – S.C.C., File No. 28452
Abrams v. Collins (No. 5)
2001 BCHRT 43
Petition dismissed – 2002 BCSC 1774

Appeal dismissed – 2004 BCCA 96

Application for leave to appeal dismissed – S.C.C., File No. 30259
Adolphs v. Boucher Institute of Naturopathic Medicine
2013 BCHRT 78
Petition dismissed – 2014 BCSC 298
Ahlwat v. City of Surrey
2001 BCHRT 21
Petition dismissed – 2002 B.C.S.C 63
Andrews v. Steelworkers of America et al
(November 29, 2006 letter decision)
Petition dismissed – 2007 BCSC 1079
Armstrong v. B.C. (Ministry of Health)
(No. 5)
2008 BCHRT 19
Petition allowed – 2009 BCSC 856

Appeal allowed – 2010 BCCA 56

Application for leave to appeal dismissed – S.C.C. Registry No. 33643
Asad v. Kinexus Bioinformatics
2008 BCHRT 293
Petitions dismissed – 2010 BCSC 33
Azagrar v. Nicholas Shaw and Shaw (No. 6),
2007 BCHRT 158
Petition dismissed for want of prosecution:
January 30, 2009

B

Complaint name and/or Tribunal decision, date and/or citationResult of judicial review, court registry information and/or decision
Baharloo v. UBC and another (No. 2)
2011 BCHRT 290
Petition dismissed – 2014 BCSC 762

Appeal dismissed –2016 BCCA 277
Bali and Bali v. Imperial Parking Canada Corporation
2003 BCHRT 92
Petition allowed – 2005 BCSC 643
Ballendine v. Willoughby and others (No. 4)
2007 BCHRT 162
Petition allowed – 2007 BCSC 2009
Bartuk v. Vancouver Coastal Health Authority
2016 BCSC 74
Petition dismissed – 2016 BCSC 74
Bates v. Overwaitea Food Group
2006 BCHRT 44
Petition allowed – 2006 BCSC 1201
Becker v. Cariboo Chevrolet Oldsmobile Pontiac Buick GMC Ltd. (No. 2)
2004 BCHRT 80
Petition allowed in part – 2006 BCSC 43
Becker v. Cariboo Chevrolet Oldsmobile Pontiac Buick GMC Ltd. (No. 3)
2004 BCHRT 139
Bellefleur v. The District of Campbell River (No.2)
2002 BCHRT 28
Petition allowed – 2003 BCSC 1109

Decision on costs – May 22, 2003 (oral reasons for judgment)

Appeal allowed – 2004 BCCA 601

Bennett v. Classy Car Care Inc.
(December 23, 1998)
Petition dismissed – BCSC Nanaimo, Registry No. S23342
Berezoutskaia v. IWA,
Sodexho and others
2005 BCHRT 133
Petition dismissed – 2005 BCSC 1170

Appeal dismissed – 2006 BCCA 95

Application for leave to appeal dismissed – S.C.C. File No. 31426
Bihari v. Deltec Electric Ltd.
2019 BCHRT 114
Petition dismissed – 2020 BCSC 1450
Bolster v. BC (Min. of Public Safety and Solicitor General)
2004 BCHRT 32
Petition dismissed – 2005 BCSC 1491

Appeal dismissed – 2007 BCCA 65

Application for leave to appeal dismissed – S.C.C. File No. 31963
Bradley v. Fire-Trol Canada Company
2005 BCHRT 212
Petition dismissed – 2005 BCSC 1646
Brady v. Interior Health Authority
2005 BCHRT 200
Petition dismissed – 2005 BCSC 1403
Brar and others v. British Columbia Veterinary Medical Association and Osborne (No. 17)
2010 BCHRT 260
Petition dismissed – 2011 BCSC 486
Breuker v. Arrowsmith Lodge Health Care Society and another
2019 BCHRT 55
Petition dismissed – 2021 BCSC 2337 (oral reasons for judgement)
Bro and Scott v. Moody (No. 2),
2010 BCHRT 8
Petition dismissed – 2012 BCSC 657
Brown v. PML and Wightman (No.3)
2008 BCHRT 118
Petition dismissed – 2008 BCSC 1429
Brown v. PML and Wightman
2007 BCHRT 377
Petition dismissed – November 26, 2008 (oral reasons for judgement)
Buntain and others v. Marine Drive Golf Club and others
2005 BCHRT 119
Petition allowed – 2005 BCSC 1434

Appeal dismissed – 2007 BCCA 17

Application for leave to appeal dismissed – S.C.C. File No. 31426
Byelkova v. Fraser Health Authority and another
2019 BCHRT 118
Petition allowed – 2021 BCSC 1312

Appeal dismissed – 2022 BCCA 205

C

Complaint name and/or Tribunal decision, date and/or citationResult of judicial review, court registry information and/or decision
Callaghan v. University of Victoria
2005 BCHRT 589
Petition dismissed – 2006 BCSC 1503
Carter v. Travelex Canada and Travelex UK (No. 3)
2007 BCHRT 275
Petition dismissed – 2008 BCSC 405

Appeal dismissed – 2009 BCCA 180
Cassidy v. Emergency Health and Services Commission and others (No. 2)
2008 BCHRT 125
Petition allowed – 2011 BCSC 1003
Caster v. Walter Evans (No. 2),
2012 BCHRT 163
Petition dismissed – February 6, 2013
(oral reasons for judgment)

Appeal dismissed – 2013 BCCA 529
CFO v. The Organization (No. 4)
2022 BCHRT 55
Petition dismissed – 2022 BCSC 1758
Chaloob v. Vancouver Police Department,
2005 BCHRT 311
Petition dismissed – 2005 BCSC 1836
Chan v. UBC and others (No. 2)
2012 BCHRT 12
Petition allowed – 2013 BCSC 942
Chaudhary v. Smoother Movers (No. 2)
2009 BCHRT 176
Petition allowed – June 29, 2012
(oral reasons for judgment)
Chen and others v. City of Surrey and others,
2012 BCHRT 284
Petition dismissed – 2014 BCSC 539

Appeal dismissed – 2015 BCCA 57
Chiang v. Vancouver Board of Education and another,
2014 BCHRT 37
Petition dismissed – 2014 BCSC 1859
Chilliwack Teachers’ Associations v. Neufeld
2021 BCHRT 6
Petitions dismissed – 2023 BCSC 1460
Chubb-Kennedy v. Edgewater Casino and another,
2013 BCHRT 213
Petition dismissed – 2014 BCSC 416

Appeal dismissed – 2015 BCCA 9
Cima v. Intact Distributors and another,
2015 BCHRT 140
Petition dismissed – May 9, 2016, oral reasons for judgment
Complainant v. College of Physicians and Surgeons of BC (No. 2),
2018 BCHRT 189
Petition dismissed – 2019 BCSC 1898
Conklin v. University of British Columbia,
2018 BCHRT 130.
Conklin v. University of British Columbia, 
2018 BCHRT 262
Petition dismissed – 2021 BCSC 1569

Appeal dismissed – 2022 BCCA 333
Corren v. Abbotsford School Board,
2010 BCHRT 32
Petition dismissed – 2011 BCSC 529
Cowie v. Grand Forks District Savings Credit Union (No. 2)
2006 BCHRT 167
Petition dismissed – 2006 BCSC 2008
Crane v. B.C. (Ministry of Health Services and others)
2005 BCHRT 361
Petition allowed – 2007 BCSC 460
Crockford v. Her Majesty the Queen in the Right of the Province of British Columbia
2004 BCHRT 78
Petition allowed – 2005 BCSC 663

Appeal allowed – 2006 BCCA 360
Crozier v. Richmond (City)
(June 30, 1998)
Petitions dismissed – B.C.S.C.Vancouver, Registry Nos. A982351, A990410

Appeal allowed – 2001 BCCA 77

D

Complaint name and/or Tribunal decision, date and/or citationResult of judicial review, court registry information and/or decision
Dadvand and Ross v. CB Richard Ellis Ltd. and others
2004 BCHRT 36
Petition dismissed – 2009 BCSC 1969
Daughter M by Mother K v. Board of Education of a Vancouver Island School District
2019 BCHRT 274
Petition allowed – oral ruling, October 15, 2020, (oral reasons for judgment)
Dean v. University of Victoria and another,
2012 BCHRT 71
Petition dismissed – August 30, 2013, (oral reasons for judgment)
Dela Merced v. Aluminum Curtain Wall System Inc.
(Letter Decision dated March 22, 2011)
2011 BCHRT 342
Petition dismissed – July 17, 2012, (oral reasons for judgment)
De Silva v. Fraser Health Authority and BCNU
(No. 2)
2011 BCHRT 195
Petition dismissed – 2012 BCSC 1710
Dixon v. Victoria Shipyards and others
2011 BCHRT 46
Employer petitions allowed , union petitions allowed in part – 2012 BCSC 161
Duncan v. Trustees: Retail Wholesale Union Pension Plan
2016 BCHRT 22
Petition allowed – 2017 BCSC 2375
Dunkley v. UBC and another
2015 BCHRT 100
Petition dismissed – July 26, 2016, 2016 BCSC 1383

E

Complaint name and/or Tribunal decision, date and/or citationResult of judicial review, court registry information and/or decision
Edwards v. Foglia and Champion Cabs
2006 BCHRT 517
Petition dismissed – 2007 BCSC 861
Engler v. Coast Mountain Bus Company and another
2009 BCHRT 206
Petition dismissed – March 11, 2010 (oral reasons for judgment)
Eva obo others v. Spruce Hill Resort and another,
2018 BCHRT 238
Petition dismissed – 2021 BCSC 2504
Evans v. UBC
2007 BCHRT 348
Petition dismissed – 2008 BCSC 1026

F

Complaint name and/or Tribunal decision, date and/or citationResult of judicial review, court registry information and/or decision
Feldman v. Westfair Foods Ltd. (c.o.b. Real Canadian Superstore)
June 11, 1997
1997 BCHRT 18
Petition dismissed April 2, 1998 (oral reasons for judgement)
Figliola and others v. Workers’ Compensation Board (No. 2)
2008 BCHRT 374
Petition allowed – 2009 BCSC 377

Appeal allowed – 2010 BCCA 77

Appeal allowed – 2011 SCC 52
Ford v. Lavender Co-operative (No. 3)
2009 BCHRT 38
Petition allowed – 2009 BCSC 1437

Appeal dismissed – 2011 BCCA 114
Forsyth v. Coast Mountain Bus Company and another (No. 2)
2011 BCHRT 133
Petition dismissed – February 2, 2012 (oral reasons for judgement)

Appeal dismissed – 2013 BCCA 257

Application for leave to appeal dismissed – S.C.C. File No. 35501
Francescutti v. City of Vancouver and another,
2014 BCHRT 236
Petition allowed – 2016 BCSC 1191

Appeal allowed – 2017 BCCA 242
Francis v. Victoria Shipyards (No. 3),
2012 BCHRT 233
Petition allowed – 2013 BCSC 1410

G

Complaint name and/or Tribunal decision, date and/or citationResult of judicial review, court registry information and/or decision
Garand v. K.E. Gostlin Enterprises Ltd. doing business as Canadian Tire Corp.
2002 BCHRT 8
Petition allowed – November 13, 2002
(Oral Reasons for Judgment)
Gardezi v. Black Press Group and another,
2011 BCHRT 123
Petition dismissed – 2012 BCSC 196
Gardezi v. The Postive Living Society of BC and another,
2017 BCHRT 63
Petition allowed in part – 2019 BCSC 666
Gareau v. Lawrence
2001 BCHRT 11
Petition dismissed – November 13, 2002 (oral reasons for judgement)
Gatica and Migrante obo Temporary Foreign Workers from Guatemala v. Golden Eagle Blueberry Farm
2020 BCHRT 214
Petition dismissed – 2022 BCSC 304
Ghinis v. Crown Packaging Ltd.
Petition allowed – 2000 BCSC 1809

Appeal allowed – 2002 BCCA 172
Gichuru v. Pallai
2012 BCHRT 327
Petition dismissed – 2017 BCSC 1083

Appeal dismissed – 2018 BCCA 78

Application for leave to appeal dismissed – S.C.C. File No. 38123
Gichuru v. Pallai (No. 2)
2010 BCHRT 125
Constitutional challenge to s. 27(1)(c) dismissed – 2018 BCSC 2220
Gichuru v. Purewal and another
2017 BCHRT 19
Petition allowed – 2019 BCSC 484

Costs – 2019 BCSC 951
Gichuru v. The Law Society of British Columbia (No. 11)
2012 BCHRT 275
Petition allowed in part – 2013 BCSC 1325

Application to re-open – 2013 BCSC 2088

Appeal dismissed – 2014 BCCA 396
Gichuru v. The Law Society of British Columbia (No. 9)
2011 BCHRT 185
Petition allowed in part – 2013 BCSC 1325

Appeal dismissed – 2014 BCCA 396
Gichuru v. The Law Society of British Columbia (No.3),
2006 BCHRT 402
Petition allowed – 2007 BCSC 1767
Gichuru v. The Law Society of British Columbia (No. 2)
2008 BCHRT 344
Petition dismissed – October 2, 2009 (oral reasons for judgement)

Appeal dismissed – 2010 BCCA 543
Gichuru v. The Law Society of British Columbia,
[Pre-Hearing Memorandum dated October 7, 2008]
Petition dismissed – 2010 BCSC 522
Gichuru v. Vancouver Swing Society
(February 1, 2017 letter decision)
Petition dismissed – 2019 BCSC 402

Appeal dismissed – 2021 BCCA 103

Leave to appeal denied – SCC File No. 39736

Reconsideration application dismissed – 2021 BCCA 246
Gichuru v. WCAT
2007 BCHRT 189
Petition dismissed – 2009 BCSC 904

Appeal dismissed – 2010 BCCA 191

Application for leave to appeal dismissed – SCC File No. 33741
Gill et al. v. British Columbia (Ministry of Health )
2001 BCHRT 34
Petition allowed in part – 2003 BCSC 1112
Gonzalez v. B.C. (Min. of Attorney General et al)
(May 13, 2008 letter decision)
Petition dismissed – 2009 BCSC 639
Gordy v. Painter’s Lodge
2000 BCHRT 16
Petition allowed – 2000 BCSC 1728

BC Human Rights Commission application to intervene dismissed – 2001 BCCA 389

Appeal allowed – 2002 BCCA 495
Graham v. NLK Consultants Inc.Petition allowed – B.C.S.C.Vancouver
Registry No. A981548
Grant v. City of Vancouver and others (No. 2),
2006 BCHRT 261
Petition allowed – 2006 BCSC 1855
Gray and others v. University of British Columbia Students’ Union – Okanagan (No. 2)
2008 BCHRT 16
Petition dismissed – 2008 BCSC 1530
Gregoire v. BC (Ministry of Public Safety)
2004 BCHRT 25
Petition allowed – 2005 BCSC 154

Appeal dismissed – 2005 BCCA 585

Application for leave to appeal dismissed –
S.C.C. File No. 31288
Gregory v. University of British Columbia
letter decision
Petition dismissed – 2022 BCSC 119
Guthrie v. LevittPetition dismissed – B.C.S.C., Vancouver Registry No. A981656

H

Complaint name and/or Tribunal decision, date and/or citationResult of judicial review, court registry information and/or decision
Hackett v. Telecommunications Workers Union and Doubt,
2011 BCHRT 18
Petition allowed – February 3, 2012 (oral reasons for judgement)
Hale v. University of British Columbia
Okanagan (No. 2)
2019 BCHRT 23
Petition dismissed – 2021 BCSC 729
Hamedanian v. Capilano University and others,
2009 BCHRT 308
Petition dismissed – February 9, 2011 (oral reasons for judgement)
Hanlon v. City of North Vancouver and another
2016 BCHRT 123
Petition dismissed – 2017 BCSC 1607
Harvey v. Gibraltar Mines Ltd. (No. 2)
2020 BCHRT 193
Petition allowed – 2022 BCSC 385

Appeal allowed – 2023 BCCA 168
Harun-ar-Rashid v. Ministry of Education (Teacher Regulation Branch)
2021 BCHRT 75
Petition dismissed – 2022 BCSC 965

BCCA Appeal dismissed; SCC leave to appeal denied – 2023 BCCA 276; SCC 40855
Hayes v. Vancouver Police Department and Barker
2005 BCHRT 590
Petition dismissed – 2006 BCSC 1217

Appeal dismissed – 2008 BCCA 148
Heilman v. Unger & The Upper Room Mission
2004 BCHRT 66
Correction
Petition dismissed – 2004 BCSC 1812
Hill v. WCAT
2008 BCHRT 253
Petition allowed – 2009 BCSC 107

Appeal allowed in part – 2011 BCCA 49
Hines v. Canpar Industries
(No. 2)
2005 BCHRT 430
Petition dismissed – 2006 BCSC 800
Hughson v. Kelowna (City)Petition dismissed – B.C.S.C.Kelowna, Registry No. 43745
Hunter v. British Columbia (Ministry of Health)
(December 21, 1999)
1999 BCHRT 65
Petition allowed – 2000 BCSC 1798
Hutchinson v. B.C. (Min. of Health)
2004 BCHRT 58
Petition dismissed – 2005 BCSC 1421

Application for stay dismissed – 2004 BCSC 1536

J

Complaint name and/or Tribunal decision, date and/or citationResult of judicial review, court registry information and/or decision
J.J. v. School District No. 43 (Coquitlam) and another
2007 BCHRT 448
2008 BCHRT 223
2008 BCHRT 360
Petition allowed – 2012 BCSC 523

Appeal allowed – 2013 BCCA 67
James obo James v. Silver Park Campsites and another (No. 2),
2011 BCHRT 370
Petition allowed in part – 2012 BCSC 1437

Appeal allowed – 2013 BCCA 292
James obo James v. Silver Park Campsites and another (No. 3),
2012 BCHRT 141
Petition allowed in part – 2012 BCSC 1437

Appeal allowed – 2013 BCCA 292
Jiwany and Jiwany v. West Vancouver Municipal Transit
2005 BCHRT 172
Petition dismissed – August 10, 2006 (oral reasons for judgement)
Johnston v. St. James Community Service Society and others
2004 BCHRT 51
Petition allowed – 2004 BCSC 1807
Johnston v. St. James Community Service Society
and others (No. 2)
2004 BCHRT 59
Petition allowed – 2004 BCSC 1807
Joinson v. Teck Coal and another
2013 BCHRT 215
Petition dismissed – 2014 BCSC 642
Joinson v. Teck Coal and another (No.2)
2013 BCHRT 300
Petition dismissed – 2014 BCSC 642
Jubran v. The Board of School Trustees of School District No. 44 (North Vancouver)
2002 BCHRT 10
Petition allowed – 2003 BCSC 6

Decision on costs – May 22, 2003 (oral reasons for judgement)

Appeal allowed – 2005 BCCA 201

Application for leave to appeal dismissed – S.C.C., File No. 30964

K

Complaint name and/or Tribunal decision, date and/or citationResult of judicial review, court registry information and/or decision
Kamali v. Affordable Housing and others
2009 BCHRT 216
Petition dismissed – 2012 BCSC 692
Karbalaeiali v. Vancouver Trolley and another
2009 BCHRT 227
Petition dismissed – 2010 BCSC 1130

Application to late file appeal materials dismissed – January 19, 2011 (oral reasons for judgement)
Kelly v. Residential Ready Mix
2002 BCHRT 40
Petition allowed – November 10, 2003
(Oral Reasons for Judgment)
Kelly v. UBC (No. 3)
2012 BCHRT 32.

Kelly v. UBC (No. 4)
2013 BCHRT 302
Petition allowed in part – 2015 BCSC 1731

Appeal dismissed – 2016 BCCA 271
Kenworthy v. Brewers’ Distributor and another
2014 BCHRT 237
Petition dismissed – 2015 BCSC 1670
Kerr v. Boehringer Ingelheim (Canada)
(No. 4)
2009 BCHRT 196
Petition dismissed – 2010 BCSC 427

Appeal dismissed 2011 BCCA 266
Kilshaw and Hallam v. Insurance Corporation of British Columbia
(May 25, 1999)
1999 BCHRT 29
Petition allowed – 2000 BCSC 580

Appeal allowed – 2001 BCCA 193
Kirk v. City of Burnaby and another
2012 BCHRT 204
Petition allowed – 2014 BCSC 155
Koehler v. Carson and Others (No. 2)
2006 BCHRT 178
Petition dismissed – 2006 BCSC 1779
Kono v. Strata Plan LMS 2685 and another
2017 BCHRT 143
Petition dismissed – June 26, 2018, 2018 BCSC 1045

L

Complaint name and/or Tribunal decision, date and/or citationResult of judicial review, court registry information and/or decision
L.M.A. v. British Columbia Human Rights Tribunal
(Letter Decision dated
July 6, 2006)
Petition dismissed – 2006 BCSC 1889
Legere v. Provincial Health Services Authority and others,
2012 BCHRT 154
Petition dismissed – 2013 BCSC 306
Lewis v. B.C. (Ministry of Public Safety and Solicitor General)
2011 BCHRT 352
Petition dismissed – 2013 BCSC 1980
Long v. City of Vancouver
2009 BCHRT 431
Petition dismissed – 2011 BCSC 643
Lord v. Fraser Health Authority and another
2020 BCHRT 64
Petition allowed – 2021 BCSC 2176
Lorenz v. Mainstream Association for Proactive Community Living
2010 BCHRT 305
Petition dismissed – February 23, 2011 (oral reasons for judgement)
Lungu v. B.C. (Min. of Children and Family Development) (No. 2),
2011 BCHRT 341
Petition dismissed – February 20, 2014 (oral reasons for judgement)

Appeal dismissed – 2016 BCCA 136

M

Complaint name and/or Tribunal decision, date and/or citationResult of judicial review, court registry information and/or decision
MacGarvie v. Friedmann
(No. 4),
2009 BCHRT 47
Petition allowed – 2011 BCSC 1147

Appeal allowed – 2012 BCCA 445
MacTavish v. Tennant (c.o.b. “Look Model Talent”)
(November 26, 1998)
1998 BCHRT 67
Petition dismissed – September 29, 1999 (oral reasons for judgement)

Petition allowed – April 5, 2000 (oral reasons for judgement)
McCormick v. Fasken Martineau Dumoulin
(No. 2)
2010 BCHRT 347
Petition dismissed – 2011 BCSC 713

Appeal allowed – July 19, 2012

Appeal dismissed – 2014 SCC 39
McCreath v. Victoria Taxi
2015 BCHRT 153
Petition dismissed – September 13, 2016 (oral reasons for judgement)

Appeal dismissed – 2017 BCCA 342

Application for leave to appeal – dismissed July 12, 2018, S.C.C. File No. 37947
McCulloch v. Fraser Health Authority, City of Surrey
(January 21, 2016 letter decision)
Petition dismissed – 2019 BCSC 624
McCulloch v. Nociar
(May 17, 2016 letter decision)
Petition allowed – 2019 BCSC 624
McDonald v. Schuster Real Estate
2005 BCHRT 177
Petition dismissed for want of prosecution:
July 12, 2006
McDougall v. Superior Building Maintenance (No. 8)
2009 BCHRT 93
Petition filed: May 1, 2009. B.C.S.C. Quesnel
Registry No. 14081
McGrath and Fox v. B.C. (Min. of Children and Family Development)
2006 BCHRT 484
Petition allowed – 2009 BCSC 180
McIntosh v. Metro Aluminum Products and another
2011 BCHRT 34
Petition dismissed – 2012 BCSC 345
McLaughlin v. Fletcher Challenge Canada Ltd.
(December 1, 1998)
1998 BCHRT 69
Petition dismissed – B.C.S.C. Victoria
Registry No. 99 0672


Appeal dismissed – 2000 BCCA 584
McNeil v. Telus Employer Solutions (TES)
2022 BCHRT 46
Petition allowed – 2023 BCSC 481
Mahmoodi v. University of British Columbia
(October 26, 1999)
1999 BCHRT 56
Petition dismissed – 2001 BCSC 1256
Matuszewski v. British Columbia (Ministry of Competition, Science and Enterprise) No. 2
2007 BCHRT 30
Petition allowed – 2008 BCSC 915
Mehar and others v. Interfor (No. 2)
2006 BCHRT 189
Petition dismissed – 2007 BCSC 201

Appeal allowed – 2008 BCCA 204
Miller v. Union of BC Performers
2020 BCHRT 133
Petition dismissed – 2021 BCSC 1054
Moore v. British Columbia (Ministry of Social Services)
(November 1, 2000)
Petition dismissed – 2001 BCSC 336
Moore v. British Columbia (Ministry of Education)
2005 BCHRT 580
Petition allowed – 2008 BCSC 264

Appeal dismissed – 2010 BCCA 478

Appeal allowed – 2012 SCC 61
Morgan-Hung v. Provincial Health Services and others (No. 4),
2009 BCHRT 371
Petition dismissed June 17, 2010 (oral reasons for judgment)

Appeal allowed in part – 2011 BCCA 122
Morton V. BC Ministry of Public Safety and Solicitor General
2018 BCHRT 245
Petition dismissed – oral ruling
Murphy v. Vancouver Island Health Authority and others,
2014 BCHRT 20
Petition dismissed – December 8, 2017, 2017 BCSC 2255
Mzite v. B.C. (Ministry of Public Safety and Solicitor General),
2012 BCHRT 53
Petition allowed – 2013 BCSC 1116

Appeal allowed – 2014 BCCA 220

Application for leave to appeal dismissed – S.C.C. File No. 36041

N

Complaint name and/or Tribunal decision, date and/or citationResult of judicial review, court registry information and/or decision
Naser v. Zellers and McNally (No. 2),
2006 BCHRT 427
Petition dismissed – 2007 BCSC 243
National Automobile, Aerospace, Transportation and General Workers of Canada (CAW-Canada) Local 111 v. Coast Mountain Bus Company (No. 9)
2008 BCHRT 52
Petition allowed in part – 2009 BCSC 396

Appeal and cross appeal allowed in part – 2010 BCCA 447
Nicolosi v. Victoria Gardens Housing Co-operative and another (No. 2),
2013 BCHRT 1
Petition dismissed – 2013 BCSC 1989
Nixon v. Vancouver Rape ReliefPetition dismissed – 2000 BCSC 889
Nixon v. Vancouver Rape Relief
2002 BCHRT 1
Petition allowed – 2003 B.C.S.C. 1936

Application for leave to intervene dismissed – 2004 BCCA 516

Appeal dismissed – 2005 BCCA 601

Application for leave to appeal dismissed – S.C.C. File No. 31633
Noël v. School District No. 23 and another, 2023 BCHRT 4
2023 BCHRT 4
Petition dismissed – 2023 BCSC 2408
Novikova v. Thompson Rivers University and another (No. 2)
2013 BCHRT 5
Petition dismissed – 2013 BCSC 2156
Ntibarimungu v. MacDonald, Dettwiler and Associates Ltd. et al
Letter decision dated December 7, 2005
Petition dismissed – April 22, 2015 (oral reasons for judgment)
Ntibarimungu v. Whistler Blackcomb / Intrawest and others
2006 BCHRT 528
Petition dismissed – 2014 BCSC 1489

P

Complaint name and/or Tribunal decision, date and/or citationResult of judicial review, court registry information and/or decision
Pardy v. Earle and others
2008 BCHRT 241
Petition allowed in part – September 10, 2009 (oral reasons for judgment)
Pardy v. Earle and others (No. 3)
2010 BCHRT 128
Petition dismissed – 2013 BCSC 179
Pardy v. Earle and others (No. 4)
2011 BCHRT 101
Petition dismissed – 2013 BCSC 179
Parent v. Independent School Authority and School
Letter decision
Petition dismissed – 2022 BCSC 570
Parent obo the Child v. The School District
2016 BCHRT 89
Petition dismissed – February 27, 2017 – 2017 BCSC 314

Appeal allowed – 2018 BCCA 136
Parent obo the Child v. The School District (No. 2)
2018 BCHRT 89
Petition allowed – 2019 BCSC 659
Parent F obo Child G v. School H and others (No. 3)
2015 BCHRT 114
Petition dismissed – 2016 BCSC 672
Patel v. Greater Vancouver Regional District,
2012 BCHRT 150
Petition dismissed – 2013 BCSC 2154
Pennock v. Centre City Drywall (No. 3),
2009 BCHRT 192
Petition dismissed – 2011 BCSC 109
Pirsel v. Northern Health Authority
2010 BCHRT 330
Petition dismissed – 2011 BCSC 1309
Pivot Legal Society v. Downtown Vancouver Business Improvement Association and another (No. 6)
2012 BCHRT 23
Petition allowed – 2015 BCSC 534

Appeal allowed – 2018 BCCA 132

Costs – 2018 BCCA 228

Application for leave to appeal dismissed – S.C.C. File No. 38157
Pivot Legal Society v. Downtown Vancouver Business Improvement Association and another (No. 3)
2009 BCHRT 408
Petition allowed – 2010 BCSC 807
Pivot Legal Society v. Downtown Vancouver Business Improvement Association and another (No. 2)
2009 BCHRT 372

2010 BCSC 807
Poirier v. WCB and others
2006 BCHRT 236
Petition dismissed – January 16, 2009, B.C.S.C. Vancouver, Registry No. S063973

Q

Complaint name and/or Tribunal decision, date and/or citationResult of judicial review, court registry information and/or decision
Quackenbush v. Purves Ritchie Equipment Ltd. doing business as Purves Ritchie
2004 BCHRT 10
Petition dismissed – 2006 BCSC 246
Qin v. Certified General Accountants Association of British Columbia (No. 2)
2005 BCHRT 171
Petition dismissed – 2005 BCSC 1662

R

Complaint name and/or Tribunal decision, date and/or citationResult of judicial review, court registry information and/or decision
Reid et al. v. City of Vancouver Police Board
2000 BCHRT 30
Petition allowed in part – 2003 BCSC 1348

Appeal allowed – 2005 BCCA 418

Application for leave to appeal dismissed – S.C.C. File No. 31171
Riddle v. Town of Gibsons
2017 BCHRT 148
Petition dismissed – June 19, 2018 (oral reasons for judgment)
Ringham v. Domcor Health Safety and Security Inc. and another
2020 BCHRT 172
Petition dismissed – 2021 BCSC 1023
Rojas v. EaglePicher Energy Products Corp. and CAW Local 114
2005 BCHRT 17
Petition granted in part – 2006 BCSC 1101
Roos v. BC Ministry of Advanced Education and others
2018 BCHRT 197
Petition dismissed – May 3, 2019 (oral reasons for judgment)
Rossiter v. Lake City Casinos Limited
2005 BCHRT 46
Petition dismissed – 2006 BCSC 88
Routkovskaia v. FPI Fireplace Products International and Millichamp,
2009 BCHRT 95
Petition dismissed – 2011 BCSC 144

Appeal dismissed – 2012 BCCA 141
RR v. Vancouver Aboriginal Child and Family Services Society
2022 BCHRT 116
Petition allowed – 2024 BCSC 97
Rush v. City of Richmond and another
2011 BCHRT 244
Petition dismissed – 2012 BCSC 1661
Rush v. Fraser Health Authority
2021 BCHRT 103
Petition allowed – 2023 BCSC 1101

S

Complaint name and/or Tribunal decision, date and/or citationResult of judicial review, court registry information and/or decision
Safaei v. Vancouver Island Health Authority
2017 BCHRT 214
Petition allowed – 2020 BCSC 1410
Salvo v. Shoppers Drug Mart
2011 BCHRT 221
Petition allowed – 2012 BCSC 1789
Sanghera v. B.C. (Ministry of Attorney General and another),
2012 BCHRT 418
Petition dismissed – September 25, 2013 (oral reasons for judgment)

Appeal dismissed – 2014 BCCA 221
Schell v. BlencoeAppeal allowed – B.C.C.A.Victoria, Registry No. V03211

Appeal allowed – 2000 SCC 44
Schnurr v. Douglas College and Greathouse
2007 BCHRT 40
Petition dismissed – February 1, 2008
(Oral Reasons for Judgment)
Schroeder v. United Steel and another
2011 BCHRT 281
Petition dismissed – June 6, 2013 (oral reasons for judgment)
Sebastian v. Vancouver Coastal Health Authority
2017 BCHRT 1
Petition dismissed – May 4, 2018, 2018 BCSC 722

Appeal dismissed – 2019 BCCA 241
Shannon v. British Columbia (Ministry of Government Services)
2000 BCHRT 52
Petition dismissed – 2001 BCSC 721
Sheikhzadeh-Mashgoul v. Clemas Contracting and another
2015 BCHRT 17
Petition dismissed – 2015 BCSC 1342

Appeal allowed – 2016 BCCA 146

Appeal allowed – 2017 SCC 62
Shilander v. Government of Canada and Provincial Government, British Columbia
(no written decision issued)
Petition dismissed – 2005 BCSC 728
Singh and another v. Workers’ Compensation Board of BC and others,
2014 BCHRT 259
Petition dismissed – January 29, 2016 (unreported decision)
Singh v. Kane Shannon & Weiler,
2012 BCHRT 139
Petition dismissed – 2014 BCSC 1043
Skytte v. C.N. Danroth Contracting Ltd.
2000 BCHRT 61
Petition dismissed – 2002 BCSC 1227
Sloane-Seale v. Swick’s Organic Landscaping and another (No. 2),
2012 BCHRT 22
Petition dismissed – 2015 BCSC 2149
Smith v. Insurance Corporation of British Columbia (ICBC) – Letter decisionPetition dismissed – 2021 BCSC 331
Solowan v. B.C. (Ministry of Attorney General) and others
2005 BCHRT 507
Petition dismissed – 2007 BCSC 752
Sones v. District of Squamish
2016 BCHRT 99
Petition dismissed – February 2, 2017, 2017 BCSC 169
Spina v. City of Kamloops
2019 BCHRT 107
Petition dismissed – 2021 BCSC 723
Stein v. Vancouver Coastal Health Authority and another (No. 2)
2014 BCHRT 227
Petition dismissed – 2017 BCSC 1268

Appeal dismissed – 2018 BCCA 264
Stone v. B.C. (Min. of Health Services) and others
2004 BCHRT 221
Petition dismissed – August 3, 2005 (oral reasons for judgment)
Suen v. Envirocon Environmental Services (No.2)
2017 BCHRT 226
Petition dismissed – August 14, 2018, 2018 BCSC 1367

Appeal allowed – 2019 BCCA 46

Leave to appeal denied – 2019 CanLII 73206 (SCC)
Swetlishoff v. B.C. (Ministry of Attorney General)
2008 BCHRT 83
Petition dismissed – 2010 BCSC 1252

T

Complaint name and/or Tribunal decision, date and/or citationResult of judicial review, court registry information and/or decision
The Employee v. British Columbia
(Human Rights Tribunal)
2020 BCHRT 36
Petition dismissed – 2020 B.C.S.C. 1706
The Officer v. The Force
2019 BCHRT 171
Petition dismissed – 2020 B.C.S.C. 1625
The Parent obo The Child v. The School District,
2018 BCHRT 89
Appeal dismissed – 2020 BCCA 333
Tokash v. Nulla Bona Holdings Ltd.Petition allowed – 2000 B.C.S.C. 502

Decision on costs – 2002 B.C.S.C. 895
Torres and others v. Langtry Industries (No. 5),
2009 BCHRT 3
Petition dismissed – 2009 BCSC 1091
Tosen v. Starbucks Coffee Company and others
2023 BCHRT 83
Application for leave to file petition dismissed – 2024 BCSC 253
Tozer v. BC (Ministry of Transportation and Highway, Motor Vehicle Branch)
(March 30, 1999)
1998 BCHRT 12
Petition dismissed – B.C.S.C. Vancouver
Registry No. A981344
Twohey v. Bartman
2003 BCHRT 55
Petition dismissed – 2004 BCSC 1211
Twohey v. Bartman
2003 BCHRT 83
Petition dismissed – 2004 BCSC 1211

V

Complaint name and/or Tribunal decision, date and/or citationResult of judicial review, court registry information and/or decision
Verkerk v. B.C. (Ministry of Employment and Income Assistance and Ministry of Children and Family Development)
2007 BCHRT 472
Petition allowed – 2009 BCSC 180

W

Complaint name and/or Tribunal decision, date and/or citationResult of judicial review, court registry information and/or decision
Wang and others v. UBC and others
2011 BCHRT 6
Petition dismissed – November 29, 2011 (oral reasons for judgment)
White v. Roxy Cabaret and Vancouver Police Board
2010 BCHRT 110
Petition allowed – March 18, 2011 (oral reasons for judgment)
Widenmaier v. Victoria Shipyards and others
2011 BCHRT 47
Employer petitions allowed, union petitions allowed in part – 2012 BCSC 161
Willis v. Blencoe, HMTQ as represented by the Ministry of Government ServicesPetition dismissed – B.C.S.C.Victoria, Registry No. 97-4616
Wilson v. Covenant House Vancouver, Letter DecisionPetition dismissed – 2021 BCSC 1876
Woo v. Nisika Community Services and others,
2007 BCHRT 144
Petition dismissed – December 19, 2007 (oral reasons for judgment)

X

Complaint name and/or Tribunal decision, date and/or citationResult of judicial review, court registry information and/or decision
X.P. obo J.R. v. The Hospital and The Correctional Centre,
2018 BCHRT 4
Petition dismissed – 2018 BCSC 2079
XS v. YP,
2015 BCHRT 97
Petition dismissed – January 20, 2016 (unpublished decision)

Y

Complaint name and/or Tribunal decision, date and/or citationResult of judicial review, court registry information and/or decision
Yang v. Venegas and others (No. 2)
2007 BCHRT 50
Petition dismissed – 2008 BCSC 1456
Yaremy v. City of Vancouver and others,
2011 BCHRT 280
Petition dismissed – 2013 BCSC 2386

Appeal dismissed – 2015 BCCA 228
Yirgaw and others v. Post 83 Cooperative Housing Association
2013 BCHRT 54 (Parranto)
Petition dismissed – December 10, 2013 (oral reasons for judgment)
Yirgaw and others v. Post 83 Cooperative Housing Association
Memorandum Decision – February 21, 2013
Petition dismissed – December 13, 2013 (oral reasons for judgment)
Young and Young on behalf of Young v. Petres
2011 BCHRT 38
Petition allowed – March 1, 2012 (oral reasons for judgment)
Yuan v. ICBC (No. 3)
2006 BCHRT 568
Petition allowed – 2008 BCSC 1703

Appeal dismissed – 2009 BCCA 279

Legislation


Rules of practice and procedure


Practice directions


Forms


Public hearings


Decisions


Leading cases


Reviews


Policies


Programs


Special programs

Glossary


Glossary

Information & guides


FAQs