Emard v. Synala Housing Co-operative, (1 December 1993), unreported, BCCHR: A member of a housing co-op had a tenancy relationship with the co-op. The co-op owned the premises. Occupants paid housing charges to the co-op. The co-op could expel a member who did not pay rent or occupancy charges (pp 21-22). Note, this is different than an equity housing co-op, as in Stephenson.
Stephenson v. Sooke Lake Modular Home Co-operative Association (No. 3), 2008 BCHRT 161. The Tribunal is not bound by the definition of tenancy in the Residential Tenancy Act or the Manufactured Home Park Tenancy Act.
Owning shares in an equity co-op does not create a tenancy. In this case, association members bought shares in the association. Those shares gave them exclusive use and possession of a specific site where they could put their mobile home. Members also paid a monthly fee. Members could only be expelled if they breached the association’s rules. There was no tenancy relationship between the association and its members.
Oloresisimo v. Oloresisimo-Esquivel, 2005 BCHRT 64: In most cases, a tenancy means that the tenant pays money or provides services in exchange for lodging (para. 17). In this case, Mr. Oloresisimo worked as a live-in-caregiver for the respondents. After they fired him, he lived with them for a few months “as a guest”. There was no tenancy while he was a guest.
Jackson v. Summerland Motel, 2016 BCHRT 120: Ms. Jackson stayed in a motel. There was no tenancy. The Tribunal considered that:
Silver Campsites Ltd. v. James, 2013 BCCA 292: A manufactured home park discriminated against Mr. James in tenancy when it refused to rent him a mobile home pad.
Even though section 10 does not set out a defence, the Tribunal will consider whether behaviour that is prima facie discriminatory is bona fide and reasonably justified: James v. Silver Campsites Ltd, 2011 BCHRT 370 at para. 186, upheld 2013 BCCA 292; Jackson v. Summerland Motel, 2016 BCHRT 120 at para. 104.
Tenant A v. Landlord, 2007 BCHRT 321: The terms and conditions of a tenancy include the services a landlord provides to their tenants, such as maintenance, security or garbage removal (para. 12).
In a complaint about another tenant’s conduct, there must be a link between the conduct and the tenancy. There may be a link in these situations:
Friedmann v. MacGarvie, 2012 BCCA 445: The Code forbids landlords from harassing their tenants based on protected characteristics. The Court of Appeal explained: “A female tenant is entitled to quiet enjoyment of her apartment free of sexual harassment in the same way that a female employee is entitled to a work environment free of sexual harassment” (para. 28).